The Only Woman in the Room: Book #review Club

The Only Woman in the Room: A Novel
by Marie Benedict
Audio Book Narrated by Suzanne Toren

audio book cover

I bought this audio book from Audible. It is based on the early life of film star Hedy Lamarr, but apparently loosely based, if the reviews at Amazon are correct.

Hedy Lamarr is something of a legend among screen stars, though most people don’t know much about her life. Coming to Hollywood in the late 1930s, she quickly realized that being known as a Jew would do her career no good, so she never talked much about her early life.

Born in Vienna to non-practicing Jews, Hedwig Kiesler was drawn to music and theater. When she was 17 or 18, she was cast in a scandalous movie called Ecstasy about a young woman married to an older man who has an affair, including nude scenes and simulated sex. The decision would come back to haunt her later.

The book starts with her appearance on the Vienna stage as their beloved Empress Elizabeth in the play Sissi. In the audience is her super fan, an older, successful man named Friedrich “Fritz” Mandl. He woos and wins her hand despite her and her parents concerns about his roguish reputation and scandalous occupation (arms merchant). Over time young Hedy realizes that Fritz is controlling and at times abusive. She is trapped in an untenable marriage.

Fritz does a lot of entertaining, sometimes social and sometimes business. During the business dinners, Hedy is “the only woman in the room” and the men spoke freely about their weapons projects and the difficulties they were facing. All of them think Hedy is just a pretty face, but she has a formidable intelligence. During the day, she reads the scientific and technical books in Fritz’s personal library, so she understands what they are talking about. When the political situation demands that Fritz embrace the Nazis, Hedy starts plotting her escape. She knows what Hitler is doing to Germany’s Jews.

Hedy Lamarr Publicity Photo for The Heavenly Body 1944

Hedy Lamarr publicity photo for the film The Heavenly Body, 1944, courtesy of Wikimedia.

She escapes in 1838 and goes to London where she finds a lawyer and files for divorce. She brought one set of jewelry, so she sells one piece to buy a ticket to the US on the SS Normandy. In London, she meets Louis B. Mayer and his wife, and he offers her a contract. The Hollywood years are less riveting thatn Hedy’s marriage to Fritz.

In Benedict’s book, Hedy is consumed by guilt for escaping from the Nazis without telling anyone what she knows and trying to warn Europe’s Jews to get out while they can. If they can.

After war breaks out, she starts thinking about the torpedo guidance problems the Germans are having. She has a vague idea of how to improve the guidance, but needs help. Then she meets avant-guarde composer George Antheil. In Paris, she had heard his Ballet Mecanique, which features countless player pianos. They start working together to come up with a way for the torpedoes to be guided by constantly changing radio signals. This was the beginning of spread spectrum technologies, which are used today in wi-fi and Bluetooth.

Wikipedia explains it best:

In 1941, Antheil and the actress Hedy Lamarr developed a radio guidance system for Allied torpedoes that used a code (stored on a punched paper tape) to synchronise random frequencies, referred to as frequency hopping, with a receiver and transmitter. This technique is now known as spread spectrum and is widely used in telecommunications. This work led to their being inducted into the National Inventors Hall of Fame in 2014.

The book ends shortly after the US Navy turns down Hedy and Geroge’s invention, presumably because she was a woman.

In the author’s note afterward, we learn that the Navy classified the patent Top Secret, and used it in the 1950s in sonobuoys.

I enjoyed the book, though the early part was more interesting, at least until the section about her and George developing their guidance system. That was interesting.

Hedy Lamarr is quite an enigma. She was beautiful and smart, a tough negotiator, and apparently a talented actress, yet her career was relatively short lived, flaming out in the 1960s. She went into seclusion in the 1970s and died in 2000.

Recommended for fans of historical fiction.

Happy Holidays to all!

Linda

As always, click on the graphic below for more great reviews in Barrie Summy’s Book Review Club.

Click icon for more book review blogs @Barrie Summy

Book Review Club: Carnegie’s Maid by Marie Benedict #review

Today I’m reviewing the audio book of Carnegie’s Maid by Marie Benedict, Historical Fiction, narrated by Alana Kerr Collins. I chose this book because the topic for my monthly readers group was birthplace fiction, and most of this book takes place in my home town of Pittsburgh, PA. The author, Marie Benedict, calls Pittsburgh home, too.

Here’s the premise of the book, from the Amazon description:

Clara Kelley is not who they think she is. She’s not the experienced Irish maid who was hired to work in one of Pittsburgh’s grandest households. She’s a poor farmer’s daughter with nowhere to go and nothing in her pockets. But the other woman with the same name has vanished, and pretending to be her just might get Clara some money to send back home.

If she can keep up the ruse, that is.

Now, Clara Kelly isn’t just any farmer’s daughter. She’s highly intelligent, clever and well-educated. Her father had political leanings and educated his daughters not just in the basics, but also in history and literature. Clara quickly adapts by aping the Anglo-Irish accents of the Martin girls, daughter of the local lord, her father’s nemesis. Clara was chosen to go to America because she’s so smart, she was seen as unmarriagable.

Because this is fiction, Clara finds herself working for Andrew Carnegie’s mother as a lady’s maid and making it up as she goes. She only gets away with it because Mrs. Carnegie came from a hard scrabble beginning as the wife of a weaver. She’s new to having a lady’s maid, not to mention the lavish life style the family can now afford, thanks to her brilliant son Andrew.

And because this is fiction, the attraction between Andrew and Clara becomes inevitable. The two mesh intellectually at first, then later emotionally, but Clara’s family is in dire straits back in Ireland and she knows her first duty is to them. Her relationship with Andrew threatens her job, and that she cannot lose.

Benedict posits Clara’s influence as the reason why Carnegie became such a philanthropist, starting early in life. In fact, no one knows why he became so determined to give away so much of his hard earned money, but he set an example that millionaires and billionaires after him have followed.

Andrew comes off as a fascinating character. A man both ruthless in business and generous in private. Apparently he had a dual nature in real life.

A less gifted author might not have pulled off this premise, but both Clara and Andrew and their relationship seemed believable. I quite enjoyed the book, including Collins’s narration. She does a great job with the various accents: Irish, Scottish and American. I also enjoyed the descriptions of Pittsburgh in the 1860’s.

I found the review printed in the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette to be informative, esp. about the author’s inspiration for the story. As the review points out, Carnegie is a towering figure in Pittsburgh’s history. I remember going to the imposing Carnegie Library downtown when I was a child. He also endowed a university, now known as Carnegie-Mellon.

Recommended for fans of Upstairs, Downstairs and Downton Abbey.

Linda

As always, click on the graphic below for more great reviews in Barrie Summy’s Book Review Club.

Click icon for more
book review blogs
@Barrie Summy